7 Comments
User's avatar
Steve Coy's avatar

There is a simpler and more practical answer that I think could work for most real world situtations along these lines, but it requires a bit of tech: eliminate the one-shot nature of the game by giving each person a persistent and checkable ID, to which reputational information can be attached, using some form of identity/trust technology. And, as it happens, as of quite recently, the community of bright and public-spirited people developing these technolgies seem to have converged upon a common standard, called "OpenVTC", where VTC stands for "virtual trust community". For more info, check out these links: https://openvtc.net/, https://www.firstperson.network, and

https://www.firstperson.network/white-paper

Note: I have no current or past business relationships with any of the people or organizations involved in developing this standard or implementations of it. That said, I do think t is likely that I will be collaborating with some of these folks in the not too distant future, so I can't claim to be a completely disinterested party.

Liv Boeree's avatar

Agreed, thanks for sharing Steve. Yes ZK proofs are one of the concepts I plan to dig into in a few week's time, I'll make sure to read this when i do.

Steve Coy's avatar

If you would like some expert "native guides" to these identity/trust technologies and the community that builds them, I highly recommend Kevin Triplett and Kaliya "Identity Woman" Young; they are two of the three or four main organizers of the Internet Identity Workshop (https://internetidentityworkshop.com/) and also the joint driving forces behind Project Weave (https://projectweave.tech/).

Thomas Francine's avatar

Hi Liv,

I love your writing and I'm all about increasing the win-win framework as well. Not enough people know the framework, and you do such an amazing job breaking it down and building on it. Thank you for all you do.

And as for this piece in particular, thank you for helping give me some additional glimmers of hope for what is such a tricky time to be living in.

Tom Nixon's avatar

Excellent article Liv, thanks. It makes me wonder whether in the real world there can ever be anything that’s truly one-shot. Maybe situations like your examples are close enough that it barely matters, but I’m not so sure. From a complex systems POV all actions will have unpredictable 2nd-, 3rd-order and beyond effects that even the most rational super-computer powered AI cannot possibly predict.

Anyway, this is the last thing I’m reading before bed and I’m gonna have some weird dreams now 🤪

Don's avatar

Although I am a retired chemist, with an MA, and keep up on things, I can't say I understand much of this, or of the video. But I have a good intuitive hit from it. Organic alignment vs forced seems great, to me. Thanks!

Guy James's avatar

I'd say that the point of Pluribus is as you say, but with the caveat that the cooperation must be freely-chosen rather than coerced from the top down. It only works if everyone is genuinely free to defect (which is why communism failed).

And of course a major failure mode is the entity which is set up to co-ordinate the cooperation realising that it is powerful enough to itself defect, thus doing the opposite of what it was set up to do, creating a zero-sum game, and winning that game (in the short term).

So we see Trump enriching himself like the mafia at the expense of the American people, for example. But there are many other examples and 'Don't trust the government' is an obvious maxim to live by, whoever is in power.