It seems that local control leads to different problems of stagnation and anti-growth.
Is the Atherton City Council acting as Village Elders to maintain the commons of neighborhood character? And thereby inadvertently or intentionally keeping the rich in and the poor out?
Empower local people as much as possible to write their own rules
Limit the power of non-local corporations over those people
Otherwise keep your noses out
Your short article would benefit from including a description of an equitably managed commons: an example of how this works.
Some argue that corporations themselves are not bad, rather its their short term goals. Do you disagree with this?
I tend not to. I tend to think its the alienation the corporate structure relies on, alienation from local human and natural needs, alienation from the workers, from human time scale.
thanks for the tips! I think it’s mostly the misalignment between the company’s short term metrics, and the sustainability of the ecosystem its extracting, but also the alienation plays a part too.
> therein lies the reason why the tragedy of the commons is so widespread today. Globalisation has grown the forces of big business AND big government so big, it’s almost impossible to keep them away from anything…
This seems pretty inaccurate to me. Which commons are you even talking about? Because I'm thinking of e.g. the climate, or the epistemic commons of the internet, which are inherently massive and global and therefore hard to manage. Housing stock is another stock where your takeaway from Ostrom fails.
Please discuss next: Audrey Tang and David Sloan Wilson :)
It seems that local control leads to different problems of stagnation and anti-growth.
Is the Atherton City Council acting as Village Elders to maintain the commons of neighborhood character? And thereby inadvertently or intentionally keeping the rich in and the poor out?
totally loving your summary:
Empower local people as much as possible to write their own rules
Limit the power of non-local corporations over those people
Otherwise keep your noses out
Your short article would benefit from including a description of an equitably managed commons: an example of how this works.
Some argue that corporations themselves are not bad, rather its their short term goals. Do you disagree with this?
I tend not to. I tend to think its the alienation the corporate structure relies on, alienation from local human and natural needs, alienation from the workers, from human time scale.
thanks for the tips! I think it’s mostly the misalignment between the company’s short term metrics, and the sustainability of the ecosystem its extracting, but also the alienation plays a part too.
> therein lies the reason why the tragedy of the commons is so widespread today. Globalisation has grown the forces of big business AND big government so big, it’s almost impossible to keep them away from anything…
This seems pretty inaccurate to me. Which commons are you even talking about? Because I'm thinking of e.g. the climate, or the epistemic commons of the internet, which are inherently massive and global and therefore hard to manage. Housing stock is another stock where your takeaway from Ostrom fails.